Traditional & Modern Tai Chi Forms – Part 1
August 24, 2015
My Tai Chi Story – Part 1: In the Beginning
January 10, 2016
Show all
Editorial # 1 September 6, 2015 – Do Chenstyle Taichi

Editorial # 1 September 6, 2015 – Do Chenstyle Taichi

Taijiquan (tai chi chuan) : Fighting vs Self Defense


Gichin Funakoshi (1868 – 1957) is known as the “father of modern karate”.  He is the founder of Shotokan Karate Do.

Mr. Funakoshi lived his life by a strict code of honor of the warrior class of his day in Okinawa, and brought karate to mainland Japan.  He was a true proponent of the warrior spirit (bushido) and followed it in his everyday life.

Mr. Funakoshi, among other things, left many famous quotes regarding the practice of karate do and all martial arts.  Below you will find two of his most famous quotes:

“Karate ni sente nashi”.  This interprets to  “There is no first attack in karate”.


“The ultimate aim of karate lies not in victory or defeat, but in the perfection of the character of its participants”.


My teacher, Grandmaster Wang Xi’an is another living example of the embodiment of martial virtue (wude).  Below I will give two accounts to demonstrate this.

The first is a story related to me years ago by a long time student of Master Wang’s.

When Master Wang was a much younger man, he had to accept a challenge from a famous Kung fu master from another village.  The reason was that he had to uphold the Chen family name (in those days it was still fairly common that martial artists made challenges).

This kung fu master was known for his skill and was considered very dangerous.

Master Wang went to the kung fu master’s village to accept the challenge.  When he met this man, he bowed and said very politely that since he offered the challenge, it was only fair that he attack first.

When the kung fu master attacked with his full force punch, Master Wang gently patted his hand, neutralized his punch, and struck him in the solar plexus with his elbow.  The kung fu master went down, and was gasping for air.  When he looked up, Master Wang was smiling calmly, and extended his hand to help the man up.  The kung fu master realized that Master Wang had barely touched him with his elbow, and if he wanted, could have easily killed him if he issued more force.  When his astonishment at Master Wang’s skill was realized, he bowed and apologized, and asked Master Wang to please teach him.

Master Wang only issued enough force to end the fight, but did not seriously injure this man.  This shows Master Wang’s true understanding of martial virtue (wude).  Had he chosen to penetrate a fraction of an inch more, the man could have been seriously injured or killed.  But Master Wang had no need to prove anything to anyone!

The second story of Master Wang is based on my first contact with him.

It was my first visit to Wushu Guan in Wenxian, first day training with  Master Wang.

He was teaching me the sequence of movements of his Laojia Yilu (Old Frame First Routine).  On the movement called Cover Hand and Punch, I was having a difficult time understanding the correct method.

Master Wang extended his wrist and told me to grab it and pull him down  (I know, sounds pretty stupid right?)  As I grabbed his wrist, the next thing I remember was getting hit in my chest with what felt like a cannonball, and my hip driving into the ground (thank goodness for that old thick padded carpet in the training hall!)  When I got over the disorientation (and nauseous feeling in my stomach) of moving faster than I probably ever have in my entire lifetime, and tried to understand how the cannonball (his shoulder strike) and my hip hitting the ground at the exact same moment was even possible… I looked up and there he was, same calm smile, and hand extended to help me up off of the floor.  And I realized that he barely touched me, and with the slightest bit more penetration on his part, I probably would have walked with a limp the rest of my life…

The important point here is, he did not hurt me (bruised ego maybe?) But the pain in my hip and chest were gone in a minute…  Again Master Wang’s lack of having to prove anything, just teaching me real taiji skills…

So maybe some of you are wondering why I took the time here to relate these stories to you, and to include Master Funakoshi’s quotes?

It is because I believe martial virtue, or Wude, is dying out.  I come across so many “masters” these days who have little or no gong fu (skill) but promote themselves as “Supreme Great Grand Masters” and parade around in flowing silk robes like strutting peacocks, and offering their opinions and making claims as to how they are the “real deal”… and about how they have the real secrets, and and and…

And for what?  What is their intention?  Is it to impress others? Is it for ego and to gain more money?

Lately I have studied many videos of these “masters” demonstrating their forms and Push Hands skills.  What I mostly see is incredibly stiff forceful movements and struggling wrestling matches between ex high school football players who haven’t distinguished the difference between football and taiji…

Please do not misunderstand me.  I am in no way saying I am the real deal, or I have received the secret training… I have practiced daily since 1969.  I consider that I have some knowledge, but I also know that I must always have the mind and attitude of a beginner each day…

There is a very famous saying in taiji also – “Never try to control anything outside yourself.  When you do, you are out of balance”.

The subtitle above is Taijiquan: Fighting or Self Defense.

Taijiquan like all martial arts is meant as a defensive art, not for attacking people!  There is a huge difference.

I am sure I will receive many comments from “masters” disagreeing…  Mostly the ones I am (subtly?) calling out!

It will always come down to semantics though.  And I truly am not interested in this.

My reason for writing this editorial is strictly to express my opinion.  I do not expect any one to agree and I will not defend my opinion for those who disagree.  You all have your opinion and that is fine.

Last story…

Upon my first meeting with Master Wang Xi’an, he brought me to a hotel room, and had me sit on a bed with 8 Chinese men all smoking continuously.  This was my interview through a translator to decide whether or not he would have time to teach me.  (Keep in mind I saved a long time and flew literally half way around the world to study with him… but it was not sure if he would teach me).  And this interview was the first step for him to decide if I was worthy of his teaching me…

He asked many questions thru the interpreter.. what I wanted to learn, who were my previous teachers, etc.  His last question I found very strange.  He asked me if I was a taiji master!

What I did not realize at the time is this was his way of testing my character to determine if he would teach me.

My response was, that although I had practiced already 30 years, I understood that this is an art, and in the end, there will always be more to learn.  So to refer to myself as a master seemed ludicrous, a waste of time.  And what purpose would it serve?  To boost my ego?  To impress other people?  How ridiculous!

Well I guss I passed the interview, because the next words from the interpreter were that Master Wang would take personal responsibility for my training, and he would teach me every day privately for 5 hours!

Hey you “grandmasters” out there.  Well, I don’t know if you will realize that this editorial was written for you!

To everyone, I hope this longwinded editorial strikes something inside of you all.  I hope we can move forward and practice Wude.  I hope innocent people who enter martial art schools will not be fooled and recognize the real from the fake…  that is all.

I thank everyone for their patience in reading this editorial.  If you took the time to read it, I hope it stimulates thought about why we do what we do…  Lets think in the direction of Wude – the spirit of martial arts.


  1. Michael Huffman says:

    I enjoyed reading this , Bob. Grab my wrist, famous last words

  2. Very good question? Yours ideas is like my. I Think, yours answer is in your question. Good Tai Chi teacher should be so like hi is not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *